423
1 INTRODUCTION
In shipping industry, as well as in other industries,
present and future trends are intensely focused on any
aspect of pollution, especially on air pollution caused
by exhaust gases. Although, ships during their voyage
or stay in port create pollution, in present researches
and analysis of pollution are increasingly determined
to obtain certain patterns in this area [6, 9]. Such
efforts are mainly driven by results of climate changes
that cause necessity for mitigating the effects of
climate changes [8].
When investigating the topic of pollution from
cruise ships, factor of great importance is seasonality
of their visits during entire year. Many papers focus
their research on air pollution caused from cruise
ships during their time spent in ports, where most
common source of data used is from the MedCruise
Association [1]. Only minority of the researches tried
to determine and analyse seasonality pattern [5].
An attempt is undertaken to analyse the seasonal
pattern for the east coast of Adriatic Sea, analysing
cruise ships and their behaviour during two
consecutive years, analysing three largest ports in the
area, Split, Dubrovnik and Kotor. Results are
presented in the paper prepared by Stanivuk et all.
[11] describing similarities and differences with the
Mediterranean pattern, bringing several new
conclusions and information, but leaving some of
questions unanswered. This team continued the
research in the same area in order to provide answers
to those questions, looking in the seasonal pattern not
only on the large scale, but dividing cruise vessels in
smaller segments.
In order to determine actual duration of cruise ship
stay in port and if there is any link to the ship size,
data collected for two-year period are analysed,
providing mean values integrated within diagrams.
Since literature review reveals that for most port calls
for cruise ships take place during summer period,
mean value is used to exclude any proportions of
extremely large or small values that can occur during
other seasons. Also, in this analysis focus is on Eastern
Adriatic Sea, which is mainly observed through its
most dominant hosting ports: Dubrovnik, Kotor and
Split.
Influence of Cruise Ship Size on Length of Stay in Port
Z. Jurić, K. Bratić, Đ. Dobrota & I. Štolfa
University of Split, Split, Croatia
ABSTRACT: How long the cruise ship is staying in port? Does that value change during the year? Is the period
linked to the number of passengers and the size of the ship? What influences overall period of the stay in port?
These questions are just a sample of questions appeared before the research team which tried to establish rules
of the Cruise ships seasonal pattern on the East Coast of the Adriatic Sea several questions appeared. Answers
to cited questions are presented in this article, obtained by analysing the behaviour of cruise vessels in three
biggest ports on the East Coast of the Adriatic Sea during the period of two years.
http://www.transnav.eu
the International Journal
on Marine Navigation
and Safety of Sea Transportation
Volume 15
Number 2
June 2021
DOI: 10.12716/1001.15.02.21
424
For this analysis ship size is divided according to
the vessel’s overall length, the group is divided into
three categories: less than 100 [m], between 100 [m]
and 200 [m] and greater than 200 [m]. In addition to
this, median value for each category is presented as a
dotted line, so it represents more consistent value for
complete period of the year. This is achieved due to
the fact that median value is less affected by any
proportions of extremely large or small values.
Median value allows easier spotting of the extremes
and easier overall pattern description.
Data analysed in this paper are provided by each
Port Authority [4, 7, 10], where vessels that have less
than 500 GT are not included in this analysis.
Analysed data in this paper refer for the period of two
years, which are presented in the form of median
value for more comprehensive presentation on does
the ship size have an influence on length of ship stay
in port.
2 NUMBER OF PORT CALLS
This part of the research deals with analysis of port
call pattern for the Eastern Adriatic Sea, with respect
to the observed period of the year 2017 and 2018.
Figure 1. and Figure 2 present number of cruise ship
port calls in 2017 and 2018 with respect to the overall
length of the ships included in this analysis. Ship sizes
are divided as in previously described manner. From
Figure 1 and 2 it can be noted that number of port
calls vary according to the size of the vessel. Largest
vessels visits are very frequent during summer while
during three (four) winter months (December,
January, February and partially November) those
vessels are not calling into East Adriatic ports. Middle
group, containing medium size cruise vessels has
similar seasonal pattern behaviour, only their winter
break includes two more months (March and April).
Both of these groups show characteristic seasonal
pattern, described in previous research [11]. Unlike
the previous two groups, the third group containing
small vessels, with the length less than 100 [m] almost
does not show any seasonal pattern, seasonal increase
of the port calls is very small, negligible when
compared to the other two groups.
Figure 1. Cruise ship port calls for Eastern Adriatic, 2017.
During the summer, there are close to 100 monthly
port calls of the vessels larger than 200 [m], about 50
of medium size vessels and less than 30 port calls of
vessels smaller than 100 [m]. During the peak period,
only about 10% of all cruise vessels calling to Eastern
Adriatic ports are smaller than 100 [m].
Figure 2. Cruise ship port calls for Eastern Adriatic, 2018.
Due to the cessation of arrivals of larger cruisers
during the winter months, the percentage of arrivals
of smaller cruisers during the winter months exceeds
90% (100% in the February).
3 CRUISE SHIPS STAY IN PORT
Stanivuk et all. [11] determined cruise ships average
stay in port which is presented on the Figure 3.
Figure 3. Eastern Adriatic coast Cruise ships average stay in
port [11]
The presented diagram shows large decline of the
stay during summer months, while during the winter
that period is longer. Analysing average stay in port
per previously described groups, the situation is
different (Figure 4 and 5). Seasonal pattern, shown on
the Figure 3 and described in the paper [11] cannot be
identified when stay in port is divided into groups.
425
Figure 4. Cruise ships stay in port for Eastern Adriatic, 2017.
During the winter, smaller ships stay in port a little
longer than in summer, about 20 hours longer which
is attributed to worse weather during the winter
months [2, 3]. Medium sized and large cruise vessels
have almost constant stay in port, when there are
ships from those groups in the port.
Figure 5. Cruise ships stay in port for Eastern Adriatic, 2018.
Inversely proportional correlation can be made
between cruise ship size and length of stay in port,
smaller vessels stay longer in the port while larger
cruisers stay very short. It should be noted that this
can only be concluded for Eastern Adriatic Sea, due to
the fact that some worldwide cruise destinations are
related with exclusively winter season. This fact can
be supported with the assumption that some ships
with length overall less than 100 [m] have navigation
area restriction and cannot travel worldwide in order
to visit attractive winter season cruise destinations.
4 CONCLUSION
Analysis in this paper was performed in order to
determine duration of cruise ship stay in ports, as well
as how that value changes and what influences that
change. To achieve such comprehensive analysis port
authority’s data were used so sample distribution of
port calls and hours spent in port could be
determined. Additionally, to provide more consistent
sample distribution a two-year period is observed and
mean value of each sample is introduced.
This study shows that during observed period
significant changes in patterns occur from April to
October, and vice versa. It can be concluded that
cruise ship size does not correlate to the number of
hours spent in ports, on the contrary ships with
smaller size tend to have longer stay time in ports
throughout whole year. Even though, cruise ships
with larger size have more passenger capacity, hours
spent in ports are lesser then on smaller capacity and
size ships. Opposite pattern is noticed for port call
point of view, meaning that cruise ships with greater
size tend to make more port calls than ships with
smaller size. Median values are used to exclude
extremely small or high values that occur during
winter time, i.e., period from October to April. This
approach provides general values that can be used
when investigating cruise ship patterns. From Figure
representing average cruise ship stay in port, it can be
concluded that it represents sum of wrong
conclusions regarding ship stay in port. This means
that it revealed in this paper that cruise ships do not
stay significantly longer in port during winter,
whereas this is caused by the absence of larger cruise
ship port calls.
Such conclusions can be attributed to the weather
conditions that are dominant in period from April to
October and period from October to April. This could
be directly related to cruise ship with smaller size,
due to the fact that they are more affected by bad
weather during winter season. In addition, it can be
presumed that such ships have restricted navigation
area which can contribute to development of
presented pattern. However, larger cruise ships are
less affected by seasonal condition during whole year
and it is safe to say that are mostly equipped with no
restrictions regarding navigation area. This leads to
presumption that such ships tend to cruise in other
seas during winter season. Future research will be
directed on investigating other possible factors that
can influence how long cruise ships stay in port and
how does these values change in some winter season
cruise destinations.
REFERENCES
1. Caballé, J., Lohrum, A., Valls, S.: 2018 Statistics Cruise
Activities in MedCruise Ports MedCruise,
https://www.medcruise.com/18-statistics-cruise-
activities-in-medcruise-ports, last accessed 2021/03/21.
2. Cavaleri, L., Bertotti, L., Tescaro, N.: The modelled wind
climatology of the Adriatic Sea. Theoretical and Applied
Climatology. 56, 3, 231254 (1997).
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00866430.
3. Dević, T.: Analysis of cyclone tracks over southern
Europe and their effects on weather in the Adriatic
region. University of Split (2020).
4. Dubrovnik Port Authority: Tariff schedule of port
services and charges of Dubrovnik port authority,
Dubrovnik, Croatia,
https://www.portdubrovnik.hr//datoteke/tariff-
eng2021final20201230111208.pdf, last accessed
2021/03/17.
426
5. Esteve-Perez, J., Garcia-Sanchez, A.: Characteristics and
consequences of the cruise traffic seasonality on ports:
the Spanish Mediterranean case. null. 44, 3, 358372
(2017). https://doi.org/10.1080/03088839.2017.1295326.
6. Fernández-Morales, A., Cisneros-Martínez, J.D.:
Seasonal Concentration Decomposition of Cruise
Tourism Demand in Southern Europe. Journal of Travel
Research. 58, 8, 13891407 (2018).
https://doi.org/10.1177/0047287518802094.
7. Kotor Port Authority: Tariff of port charges and other
services, Kotor, Montenegro,
http://www.portofkotor.co.me/Tarifa%20luckih%20nakn
ada%20i%20drugih%20usluga%20LUKA%20KOTOR%2
0AD%20KOTOR.pdf, last accessed 2021/03/17.
8. Merico, E., Dinoi, A., Contini, D.: Development of an
integrated modelling-measurement system for near-real-
time estimates of harbour activity impact to atmospheric
pollution in coastal cities. Transportation Research Part
D: Transport and Environment. 73, 108119 (2019).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trd.2019.06.009.
9. Perdiguero, J., Sanz, A.: Cruise activity and pollution:
The case of Barcelona. Transportation Research Part D:
Transport and Environment. 78, 102181 (2020).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trd.2019.11.010.
10. Split Port Authority: Tariffs of port dues port authority
Split, Split, Croatia, https://portsplit.hr/wp-
content/uploads/tariffes-of-port-dues-july-2016_1-1.pdf,
last accessed 2021/03/15.
11. Stanivuk, T., Mišura, A., Stazić, L., Štolfa, I.:
Determination of the cruise vessels seasonal pattern in
Eastern Adriatic. (2021).